5 Things Real Estate Agents Get Wrong About AI (And What to Do Instead)

I’ve lost count of how many times I’ve heard this: “Yeah, we tried AI. It doesn’t really work for real estate.”

Every time, I ask the same question: “What did you try?”

And every time, it’s some version of the same story. They opened ChatGPT, typed something vague, got something generic, and wrote off the entire technology. It’s like test-driving a Ferrari in first gear around a car park and concluding it’s slow.

AI isn’t magic. But it’s not useless either. The problem isn’t the technology — it’s how agents are using it. After working with sales teams across enterprise and real estate, I keep seeing the same five mistakes. Over and over. Like clockwork.

Here’s what they are, why they happen, and what actually works instead.

---

Mistake #1: Expecting Magic from a Single Prompt

This is the big one. The origin story of almost every “AI doesn’t work” belief in real estate.

Here’s how it goes: an agent hears the hype, opens ChatGPT on a Tuesday night, types “write me a listing description for a 3-bedroom house,” and gets back something that reads like it was scraped from a 2009 template site. Naturally, they conclude that AI is overhyped nonsense.

That’s like judging a phone by making one call to a wrong number.

What’s actually happening: Without context, AI has nothing to work with. It doesn’t know the property. It doesn’t know the suburb. It doesn’t know your target buyer, the local market, or whether the place has a harbour view or looks directly into the neighbour’s bathroom. So it does what anyone would do with zero information — it guesses. And it guesses generically.

A real-world example: I watched an agent type “write a listing for a property in Port Macquarie” into ChatGPT. The output mentioned “vibrant city living” and “cosmopolitan dining.” Port Macquarie. Cosmopolitan dining. The agent showed me like it was proof AI was broken. No mate — you just didn’t tell it you’re selling a coastal three-bedder near Lighthouse Beach to a young family relocating from Sydney.

The fix: Context is everything. A good prompt includes property details (beds, baths, standout features), suburb character, target buyer profile, and the tone you want. The difference between a lazy prompt and a detailed one isn’t incremental — it’s the difference between garbage and something genuinely useful.

If you want to see what this looks like in practice, we broke down the exact process in How to Write Listing Descriptions in 60 Seconds with AI. Spoiler: the prompt does about 80% of the work.

---

Mistake #2: Using AI Without Your Voice

Here’s a fun experiment. Go to realestate.com.au right now and read five listing descriptions from five different agencies. I’ll wait.

They all sound the same, don’t they?

“Boasting an abundance of natural light, this stunning residence offers the perfect blend of modern living and coastal charm.”

That sentence could be selling literally any property in any coastal town in Australia. And now that every second agent is using AI with the exact same default prompts, it’s getting worse. Every agency is producing the same beige output because they’re all feeding AI the same nothing and getting the same nothing back.

What’s actually happening: Generic prompts produce generic output. When you don’t give AI any reference for your brand voice, your writing style, or your agency’s personality, it defaults to “real estate robot.” And real estate robot sounds like every other real estate robot.

A real-world example: A principal showed me two listings her team had produced with AI. She couldn’t tell which agent wrote which — and neither could I. They’d completely lost the voice that made their agency recognisable. Their top agent had a distinctive, warm, slightly cheeky style that buyers loved. The AI versions? Soulless.

The fix: Train AI on YOUR voice. Feed it your best past listings. Give it examples of your top-performing descriptions and say “write in this style.” Give it your agency’s brand guidelines if you have them. Tell it “we never use the word ‘boasting’ and we always mention the neighbourhood, not just the house.”

The agencies getting the best results from AI aren’t the ones with the fanciest tools. They’re the ones who spent thirty minutes teaching AI how they sound. After that, the output reads like it came from their best agent — not from a machine. For a deeper dive on setting this up across your whole operation, check out our Complete Guide to AI in Real Estate.

---

Mistake #3: No Process Around AI Output

This one makes me wince every time I see it.

An agent generates a listing description with AI, gives it a two-second glance, copies it, pastes it into the CRM, and hits publish. Then a buyer calls to ask about the “spacious foyer” in what is very clearly a two-bedroom unit with no foyer. Or the listing mentions a “north-facing living area” when the lounge actually faces south-west and gets approximately zero afternoon sun.

AI hallucinated. And nobody caught it.

What’s actually happening: AI is a first draft machine, not a final draft machine. It’s incredibly good at getting you 85% of the way there in about 30 seconds. But that last 15% — fact-checking, local accuracy, making sure the description actually matches the property — that’s still on you.

The good news? Editing a solid first draft takes two minutes. Writing from scratch takes twenty. That’s still a massive win. You just can’t skip the editing step entirely.

A real-world example: An agency I worked with had an agent publish a listing that described “easy walking distance to the train station.” The property was in a town that hasn’t had passenger rail service in decades. A buyer actually mentioned it at an open home. Awkward doesn’t begin to cover it.

The fix: Build a simple review step into your workflow. AI generates the draft. A human spends two minutes checking facts, adjusting tone, and confirming the description matches reality. That’s it. No complicated process. No committee. Just one quick read-through before you hit publish.

Think of it like spell-check. You wouldn’t publish a listing without running spell-check. Treat AI output the same way — trust but verify.

---

Mistake #4: Comparing AI to the Wrong Benchmark

“AI can’t replace a good copywriter.”

You’re right. It can’t. But nobody said it should.

This is the mistake that keeps the most agencies stuck. They compare AI output to the best-case scenario — a professional copywriter who’s been briefed for an hour, has toured the property, and has three days to craft the perfect description. And sure, that copywriter will beat AI every time.

But here’s the question that actually matters: is that what you’re currently doing?

Because what I see most agents actually doing is one of two things. Either they’re copying their last listing description and doing a find-and-replace (“3 bedroom” becomes “4 bedroom,” “Lighthouse Beach” becomes “Shelly Beach,” done). Or they’re writing something original at 10:47pm after a fourteen-hour day, half-watching MasterChef, and the result reads exactly like you’d expect.

What’s actually happening: Agents are comparing AI to perfection when they should be comparing it to reality. And reality, for most agents, is mediocre descriptions knocked out under time pressure. AI doesn’t need to be perfect. It needs to be better than what you’re actually doing right now.

A real-world example: I asked a principal to pull the last twenty listing descriptions her team had published. Twelve of them had near-identical opening sentences. Three mentioned features the properties didn’t have (copied from previous listings and never updated). One still had the previous property’s address in it. These were the descriptions AI was being compared to unfavourably.

The fix: Be honest about your current benchmark. If you’re already producing brilliant, tailored descriptions for every listing — great, AI might only save you time, not quality. But if your current process involves any amount of copy-pasting, late-night rushing, or “that’ll do” energy, AI is an upgrade. A significant one.

The real comparison isn’t AI vs. the best copywriter you’ve never hired. It’s AI vs. what’s actually going live on your listings page today.

---

Mistake #5: Waiting for “The Right Time”

“We’ll look at AI once things settle down.”

Things will not settle down. Things have never settled down. The entire history of real estate is things not settling down.

“We’ll adopt AI when we’re bigger.” You’ll be bigger faster if you adopt AI now.

“Maybe next quarter.” You said that last quarter.

This is the most expensive mistake on the list because it doesn’t feel like a mistake. It feels prudent. Sensible. Like you’re being careful. But while you’re being careful, your competitors are saving nine-plus hours per agent per week and reinvesting that time into prospecting, client relationships, and winning the listings you’re too busy writing descriptions for.

What’s actually happening: The agencies adopting AI aren’t doing it because they have spare time. They’re doing it because they don’t. They’re stretched thin, they’re drowning in admin, and they’ve realised that doing everything manually isn’t a badge of honour — it’s a bottleneck.

A real-world example: Two agencies in the same market. Same size, similar listings. One started using AI for listing descriptions, buyer emails, and database nurture six months ago. Their agents now spend an average of nine hours less per week on content and admin. They’ve reinvested that into prospecting. Their listing volume is up. The other agency is “still thinking about it.” They’re working the same hours and wondering why they’re falling behind.

Those nine hours aren’t hypothetical, by the way. When you add up listing descriptions, buyer match emails, social posts, database communications, and follow-up sequences — the time AI saves is staggering. If you’re curious what your database alone is worth with proper AI-powered nurture, the maths might surprise you.

The fix: Start small. Pick one task — listing descriptions are the obvious first move. Spend an afternoon setting up good prompts with your brand voice. Use it for your next three listings. Measure the time saved. Then expand from there.

You don’t need to transform your entire business on a Monday. You need to stop waiting for a Monday that never comes.

---

The Pattern Behind Every Mistake

If you zoom out, all five mistakes share the same root cause: treating AI like a product you buy instead of a capability you build.

Products work out of the box. Capabilities take setup, iteration, and a bit of thought. The agencies getting incredible results from AI didn’t just sign up for a tool and hope for the best. They invested a small amount of time upfront to set it up properly — good prompts, their voice, a review process, realistic expectations, and the courage to just start.

That investment? A few hours. The return? Hundreds of hours saved every year, per agent.

The gap between agencies that dismiss AI and agencies that leverage it isn’t talent, budget, or tech-savviness. It’s simply whether they made these five mistakes and stopped — or pushed past them.

---

What to Do Next

If you’ve recognised your agency in one (or more) of these mistakes, you’re not behind. You’re just at the starting line. The good news is that every single one of these mistakes is fixable in a week, not a quarter.

Not sure which mistakes your agency is making? Our free AI Assessment gives you a personalised breakdown in 30 minutes. We’ll look at your current workflows, identify where AI can save the most time, and give you a practical roadmap — no jargon, no upsell, just clarity.

Book your free AI Assessment at headlanddigital.com.au/assessment

If you’re evaluating outside help, make sure you read our guide on what to ask before hiring an AI consultant — it’ll save you from the hype merchants. And if you want to see the numbers behind your existing database, try the Database Value Calculator or the ROI Calculator to quantify exactly what AI could save you.